REPORTS OF CASES DECIDED IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OREGON FRANK A. TURNER REPORTER VOLUME 99 FROM JANUARY 25, 1921, TO MARCH 22, 1921 SAN FRANCISCO BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY 1921 Copyright 1921 BY BANCROFT-WHITNEY COMPANY OCT 4 1921 SAN FRANCISCO OFFICERS OF THE SUPREME COURT. GEORGE H. BURNETT... CHARLES A. JOHNS.. LEE MOOREHOUSE... ISAAC H. VAN WINKLE... WILLIS S. MOORE.. PERRY H. RAYMOND... EDWARD N. GILLINGHAM... .CHIEF JUSTICE .ASSOCIATE JUSTICE . ASSOCIATE JUSTICE . ASSOCIATE JUSTICE . ASSOCIATE JUSTICE . ASSOCIATE JUSTICE ASSOCIATE JUSTICE . CLERK .DEPUTY AT SALEM DEPUTY AT PENDLETON ...REPORTER .ATTORNEY GENERAL ...ASST. ATTORNEY GENERAL .ASST. ATTORNEY GENERAL ASST. ATTORNEY GENERAL ..BAILIFF .LIBRARIAN (iii) DEPARTMENT No. 1. JUSTICE HENRY L. BENSON, Presiding Judge. JUSTICE THOMAS A. MCBRIDE. JUSTICE LAWRENCE T. HARRIS, DEPARTMENT No. 2. JUSTICE CHARLES A. JOHNS, Presiding Judge. JUSTICE HENRY J. BEAN. JUSTICE GEORGE M. BROWN. GEORGE H. BURNETT, Chief Justice. The Chief Justice, when present, will preside in both departments; is his absence the presiding judge. The Chief Justice at any time may change a justice from one department to the other. By order of the Chief Justice, a case may be heard by the court sitting in banc, either before or after argument. In any case heard before a department, three justices must coneur to render a valid judg ment. (iv) JOHN S. COKE, Marshfield. GEORGE F. SKIPWORTH, Eugene. PERCY R. KELLY, Department No. 1, Albany. JOHN P. KAVANAUGH, Department No. 1, Portland. ROBERT G. MORROW, Department No. 2, Portland. ROBERT TUCKER, Department No. 3, Portland. GEORGE W. STAPLETON, Department No. 4, Portland. WILLIAM N. GATENS, Department No. 5, Port- JOHN MCCOURT, Department No. 6, JAMES U. CAMPBELL, Oregon City. } GILBERT W. PHELPS, Pendleton. Seventh Judicial District— Hood River.. Eighth Judicial District Baker FRED W. WILSON, The Dalles. GUSTAV ANDERSON, Baker. |