 | Harold Edgar Barnes, B. A. Milner - 1924 - 440 strani
...the right to coal consists in the right to mine it:" Com. v. Clearview Coal Co., 256 Pa. 328, 331. What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...constitutional purposes as appropriating or destroying it. This we think that we are warranted in assuming that the statute does. It is true that in Plymouth... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1924 - 1212 strani
...mine it." Com. ex rel. Keator v. Clearview Coal Co. 256 Pa. 3'JS, 331, LRA 1917E, 672, 100 Atl. 820. What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...constitutional purposes as appropriating or destroying it. This [415] we think that we are warranted in assuming that the statute does. It is true that in Plymouth... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1924 - 748 strani
...right to mine it." Commonwealth v. Clearview Coal Co., 25G Pa. 328, 331, 100 Atl. 820, LRA 1917E, 672. What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...nearly the same effect for constitutional purposes as appro•415 priating or destroying it. This *we think that we are warranted in assuming that the statute... | |
 | 1924 - 440 strani
...mine it." And as is said in Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mnlion ct a!., 43 Sup. Ct. 158, 67 L Ed. — : "What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...constitutional purposes as appropriating or destroying it." (5) As the value of the ownership of coal or mineral lands consists in the right to mine it, so the... | |
 | American Bar Association - 1927 - 1190 strani
...Mr. Justice Holmes said: "For practical purposes, the right to coal consists of the right to mine it. What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...be exercised with profit. To make it commercially impractical to mine certain coal has very nearly Hie same effect for constitutional purposes as appropriating... | |
 | United States. Congress. House. Committee on Ways and Means - 1935 - 684 strani
...late Justice Holmes said: For practical purposes, the right to coal consists in the right to mine it. What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that it can he exercised with profit. To make it commercially impractical to mine certain coal has very nearly... | |
 | United States. Congress. Senate. Committee on Banking and Currency - 1948 - 1026 strani
...of cities where the right to mine such coal has been reserved. To make it commercially impracticable has very nearly the same effect for constitutional purposes as appropriating or destroying it." I quote Justice Holmes in his decision in this case: "The protection of private property in the fifth... | |
 | 1925 - 1624 strani
...said in Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 US 393, 67 L. ed. 322, 28 ALR 1321, 43 Sup. Ct. Rep. 158: "What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that...constitutional purposes, as appropriating or destroying it." As the value of the ownership of EKERN. 37 9k NW 1SÍ.) coal or mineral lands consists in the right... | |
| |
What makes the right to mine coal valuable is that it can be exercised with profit. To make it commercially impracticable to mine certain coal has very nearly the same effect for constitutional purposes as appropriating or destroying it. 
